Sunday Salon Book Review: Stalking Irish Madness by Patrick Tracey

2008 at 12pm     Posted by Rebecca Joines Schinsky

It’s been kind of a blah reading week for this book lady. I only reviewed one book–The Sex Lives of Cannibals–and it felt like it took me forever to finish it. I did have some fun blog posts, though. Have you seen my Deserted Island Reading List? What would you take with you for a long trip to a desolate place? On Wednesday I dished about my guilty pleasure summer TV shows and posted a few photos from my library wedding, and Thursday I shared favorite library memories and a few more photos. Yesterday, I borrowed the Book Brahmins questionnaire from Shelf Awareness and had a little getting-to-know-me moment.

Last night I finished Stalking Irish Madness for Library Thing Early Reviewers. Here’s my review.

Available for purchase August 26, 2008.

I received this book from Library Thing Early Reviewers.

On a crisp autumn day in 1924, Patrick Tracey’s great-great-grandmother May Sweeney (who was 29 years old at the time) left her home in County Roscommon, Ireland dressed in her finest clothing and jewelry. When she wasn’t home by dusk, her husband Jack began to worry. It wasn’t like May to stay out so late in a potentially dangerous part of town. Jack knew that May had been changing; once cheerful and lively, she had become increasingly aloof and melancholy, but he didn’t expect this:

At last Jack sees May’s figure approaching in the murky darkness. In her white-gloved finery, she moves up the walkway. But something is amiss: she is clutching her shoes; her hat is cocked, her makeup smudged. May stands in the middle of the road, her shoeless feet swollen and reddened, hard-worn, it would seem, from hours of walking. She says nothing, but as Jack goes out the gate to meet her, her slow grin says it all: every tooth has been wrenched from May’s head–her gums a swollen and bloody mess.

May reveals to Jack that she has been hearing voices who told her that they would leave her alone if she would remove them from her dental cavities. Of course, the voices lied. They continued to plague May, who suffered from schizophrenia for the rest of her life and is the first in a long line of the author’s family members to fall victim to this

apolocalyptic form of madness [that] robs its of our most precious human gift: the ability to separate the real world from the unreal and to trust one’s thoughts as true.

The schizophrenia in Tracey’s family is passed down his mother’s side, and its appearance is unpredictable and often skips a generation. The victims include Tracey’s great-great-grandmother, his grandmother, one of his uncles, and two of his four sisters. Counting himself as “a genetic near miss,” Tracey sets out for Ireland on a quest to uncover the history of the madness that has plagued his family for four generations. It has the potential to be an amazing journey, but Tracey doesn’t find much.

Though the beginning of the book and Tracey’s descriptions of his family’s history with schizophrenia are compelling—-his firsthand accounts of watching the illness overtake his sisters are particularly gripping—-the rest of the book falls flat. In fact, the middle two-thirds of Stalking Irish Madness read much more like a travelogue than a research project or case history. Tracey provides increasingly extraneous details about the weather, the countryside, and the colorful folks he meets at the local pubs (not to mention a few self-indulgent passages about his own struggles with substance abuse), and this book lady had the sense that he was doing so in order to fill the pages, to have something to talk about since his inquiries about schizophrenia and local history were continually fruitless.

In his travels, Tracey does meet and interview a few schizophrenia researchers, and the information they provide is both interesting and frustrating, due to the fact that what little we know about the disease has made us only more aware of how much we don’t know. In general, Tracey’s descriptions and explanations of schizophrenia are thoughtful, well-written, and accurate, which makes this a good book for those readers interested in a very general introduction to schizophrenia. Tracey’s exploration of the links between socioeconomic problems and mental illness are also interesting and worthwhile, but, on the whole, the book leaves much to be desired.

I was very interested in the premise of this book and thought it had (and still has) the potential to be a very interesting story. However, I was very frustrated by the fact that it really isn’t a book about Tracey exploring his family history; it’s a book about Tracey trying to explore his family history, not having much luck, and so paying much more attention to the scenery and local color than he should have. At only 257 pages, the book is a relatively short, but it could have (and should have) been much shorter.

If nothing else, this could have been a great book for introducing lay people to a better understanding of mental illness. Tracey could have focused on the research he did and the academics and doctors he interviewed, and it would have been very interesting and informative. As I read, I realized that the book, as it is written, would actually have worked much better as a documentary film. We could follow Tracey on his quest, see the sights for ourselves, share his frustration in finding few answers, and come to our own conclusions. As a book that was supposed to be about tracing family history, though, it just doesn’t work. Tracey does not do what he says he is going to do; there is very little family history within this book that is ostensibly focused primarily on uncovering such secrets.

That said, Tracey’s writing isn’t half bad, and he does a decent job of exploring the potential causes and correlates of schizophrenia. He asks why, in a family plagued by the illness, some people develop the disease while others don’t, and he resists the very appealing temptation to wallow in self-pity for what his family has lost. I didn’t love Stalking Irish Madness, but I didn’t hate it, either. It would be a good introduction to schizophrenia for anyone interested in very basic information, and I’m sure it would be an interesting read for other people whose families have experienced similar plagues of madness or disease. I’m giving it 3 out of 5.

UPDATE: Click here to listen to an NPR interview with author Patrick Tracey.